A fitness tracker helped challenge a murder suspect’s account of a home invasion. In the Connecticut case involving Connie Dabate, investigators found that her Fitbit recorded movement after the time her husband claimed she had been killed.
The data became part of a broader collection of evidence used against Richard Dabate, who was convicted of murder. In 2025, the Connecticut Supreme Court upheld the trial court’s decision to admit the Fitbit evidence.
The case illustrates why wearable data matters in criminal investigations. Heart rate, step counts, and sleep estimates can help establish timelines, but they’re not infallible. Their accuracy and significance depend on the device, the circumstances, and other available evidence.
If wearable information becomes relevant to a criminal case, four decisions deserve careful attention.
Decide Whether the Wearable Helps You or Hurts You
The first question is what the device actually recorded and how those readings compare with other evidence.
Sometimes wearable data may support someone’s account. Activity records could help corroborate a reported sequence of events, while sleep estimates might provide context for an individual’s recollection of the night.
Other times, the records may raise questions. In the Dabate case, movement data conflicted with the husband’s description of when his wife was killed. Investigators also considered other evidence, including electronic records and information gathered at the scene.
A criminal defense attorney can help evaluate relevant wearable records and determine whether they support, contradict, or simply fail to address the allegations. Importantly, having an attorney review existing data doesn’t automatically make that underlying information privileged. Decisions about disclosure should be based on the applicable legal requirements and the circumstances of the case.
Decide Who Pulls the Data, and How Fast
Wearable records may be stored on a device, a connected phone, or a manufacturer’s servers. Available information and retention periods vary, making timely preservation important. There are several potential ways to obtain relevant records:
- Account export. Some services let users download their activity history. Google’s health-data export instructions describe how account holders can request copies of available activity, sleep, and heart-rate information.
- Preservation request. An attorney may contact a provider to request that relevant records be retained. Whether the company must comply depends on applicable law and the circumstances; sending a letter alone doesn’t guarantee preservation.
- Legal process. Depending on the records sought and the applicable law, investigators may use a warrant, subpoena, or other authorized process to request information from a provider.
Each method has limitations. A personal export may require additional authentication, while records obtained directly from a provider still need to be evaluated for completeness and reliability. If wearable data may be relevant to an investigation, preserving existing information without altering or deleting it is generally preferable to waiting until records become unavailable.
Decide Whether to Challenge the Accuracy
A timestamp or heart-rate reading can look objective to a jury. But consumer wearables estimate activity using sensors and algorithms that aren’t equally reliable under every condition.
Wrist movement may affect step counts. Heart-rate accuracy can vary with device placement, movement, and sensor performance. Sleep estimates are also different from measurements obtained through a clinical sleep study.
A review of consumer wearable accuracy found meaningful variation across devices and measurements, including limitations in sleep and activity estimates. That doesn’t make the information worthless. It means the reliability of a particular reading should be examined rather than assumed.
The Connecticut Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Dabate illustrates this distinction. The trial court heard expert testimony about the Fitbit model involved and found its step data sufficiently reliable for admission.
For a defense attorney, the relevant questions may include whether the device was worn correctly, whether it was synchronized, how the data was interpreted, and whether other records support the proposed timeline.
A general argument that wearables sometimes make mistakes may carry less weight than evidence identifying a specific limitation affecting the readings in question.
Decide What to Say Before You Know What the Data Says
A person questioned during an investigation may give an approximate timeline without realizing that a smartwatch or fitness tracker contains potentially relevant information.
Later, investigators might compare that statement with activity records, phone data, surveillance footage, or other evidence. An inconsistency doesn’t necessarily prove dishonesty, but it may require explanation.
The safest approach isn’t to guess at precise times or offer a strategically vague account. It’s to be truthful, avoid speculation, and understand that people generally have the right to decline voluntary police questioning and seek legal advice.
A person who is uncertain about a timeline can say so rather than presenting an estimate as a fact. Someone facing potential criminal allegations should consider speaking with counsel before agreeing to an interview.
Wearable data can support a defense, complicate an explanation, or have little relevance at all. Its value depends on the full record, not a single number on a screen.
When a criminal investigation involves digital activity records, preserving the information and obtaining qualified legal guidance can make a meaningful difference in how that evidence is understood.
